How do you break a 50/50 parenting time fight in divorce mediation?

Short answer

Don't start with the number. Start with the story. Each parent describes, from beginning to end, a workable Tuesday: who gets the child up, who does school drop-off and pickup, homework, dinner. Then a workable Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday. Put the two real weeks side by side. The percentages still cash out at the end, but they stop being the structure of the argument, and the conversation starts to move. Ryan points to Norway's parenting-time agreement as an example: as he describes it, it's one page, built from the family's actual days, with no percentage structure on it.

Pick my free 15-min call time

15 minutes, free. Or text Ryan: (763) 316‑8323

4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews
Ryan answers it · on video

Watch on YouTubeRead the transcript

Transcript

In Ryan’s words.

What Ryan says in the video, written out.

I'm going to break a 50-50 fight without arguing about percentages. I'm going to help folks come to a resolution on 50-50 parenting time without talking those numbers. So here's the moment I see as a divorce mediator every single week. One parent says 50-50, the other parent's like, no, no, no, no, no, no. I've done everything for the entire life of this kid. 75-25, 75-25 at most. Mediation is pointless. There's nothing to talk about and negotiate. And if you disagree with me, I'm not going to lawyer, I'm not going to court. If we start with that couple with numbers, we're toast. We're buttered toast, end of conversation. There's nothing left to talk about. And so I don't start there. And the research says that it's a bad idea to start there. Instead, I start with a story. I ask each person, individually or collectively, both work, to describe from beginning to end a workable Tuesday, and then a workable Wednesday, and then a workable Thursday, and then a workable Friday. Not a fantasy Tuesday, but like an actual Tuesday. Who gets your daughter up? Who does school drop-off? Who does school pickup? Who does homework? Who does dinnertime? And then the other parent does the same. And like, they might have different answers based on their proposed schedule, but we're starting with the story and not the schedule. And so now we have two real Tuesdays, preferably side by side. And of course, yes, the percentages, they cash out at the end. They're there at the end. They're in the back of the people's mind, of course, but they're not the structure of the argument. And just going through this process has a softening of empathetic effect. And you start stacking those softening empathetic effects, you can get movement, a little bit of movement, but gets a lot of movement. And you can see countries do this. Norway's parenting time agreement is one page and there isn't a single percentage structure on there. So the principle is start with a story and the numbers take care of itself. Question for you is if you're in this space, how would you describe your Tuesday, your workable Tuesday for your kiddo right now? What's the hardest part of the day to cover? Leave it in the comments.

A tool for this, from Flannel People

Two-Home Calendar and Expense Template$29

A 12-month shared calendar, a holiday rotation, and a shared-expense tracker, for Excel or Google Sheets.

See the template
Ryan McLaughlin, divorce mediator in St. Paul, Minnesota, on a Zoom call
Ryan McLaughlin · St. Paul

Who’s answering

Ryan McLaughlin, mediator. Flannel, not a suit.

Ryan founded Flannel People Mediation in St. Paul and mediates divorces for couples all over Minnesota, mostly on Zoom, for one flat fee. He has an MFA in creative writing and a lot of kitchen-table money conversations behind him. Flannel People has 4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews. Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, so he doesn’t give legal advice or take sides.

Questions

What people ask next.

Something not here? Text Ryan.

Why not just split the difference between 50/50 and 75/25?

Because the fight usually isn't about the number. It's about the days underneath it. School mornings, homework, dinner, bedtime. When both parents describe their actual week, the disagreements get specific and smaller, and specific disagreements can be worked through one at a time. A percentage split down the middle skips all of that and leaves both people unhappy with a schedule nobody designed.

What if my co-parent won't describe their week?

That's what the start of the process is for. Before any joint session, your mediator meets each person privately for a one-on-one call, and the homework for the session is built from those calls, so nobody meets a hard question for the first time in the session itself. Describing a Tuesday is a much easier first step than defending a percentage.

Does the percentage not matter, then?

It matters. It just works better as the result of the conversation than as the opening argument. Once two real weeks are on the table, the time split is whatever those weeks add up to, and both parents can see why.

What does a parenting-time mediation session look like?

One 3-hour virtual session for most couples. Your mediator states the ground rules out loud at the start, keeps the conversation to one issue at a time, and makes sure the quieter person gets the floor. During the session, you write the agreement together, in your own words. The whole mediation process, from the first call to that agreement, usually runs one to two weeks.

How much does it cost, and can I start on my own?

Divorce mediation is $1,695 per person, flat, with no hourly billing. You can book the free 15-minute consultation by yourself. Ryan will not contact your spouse, and nothing is scheduled until you've both said yes. Already divorced and changing a schedule? That's post-divorce mediation, $995 per person, flat. See parenting time mediation in Minnesota.

Keep reading

We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice.

The free call

Pick a time. 15 minutes.

I call you at the time you pick. Come alone or together. You tell me where things stand, I tell you honestly whether mediation fits, and you don’t agree to anything on the call.

Loading scheduler...

Educational Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice, therapeutic advice, or therapy. Flannel People Mediation is a mediation service provider only. We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice. We do not provide therapeutic services. For legal questions, talk to your own attorney or the court's Self-Help Center.

Flannel People Mediation provides mediation services only. Ryan McLaughlin does not provide legal, insurance, valuation, tax, financial, or business advice, and mediation does not replace your own counsel or advisors.

Follow our work in Google

Tell Google you want to see more of our writing on divorce and mediation. It takes one tick of a box, and it changes your results, not ours.

Make us a preferred source