Stuck on 50/50 parenting time? Why trying each schedule beats splitting the difference

Short answer

Splitting the difference rarely settles a 50/50 standoff, because the fight usually isn't about the number. One parent is asking to be treated as an equal parent. The other is worried about the kids' routine and about who has been handling the day to day. Meeting in the middle at 9 overnights and 5 answers neither of them. What your mediator can offer instead: agree to try each parent's schedule for a set stretch, keep track of how it actually goes, and come back to look at it together. Trying something for a while is easier than giving up a position for good, and doing it together tends to change how two parents see each other.

Pick my free 15-min call time

15 minutes, free. Or text Ryan: (763) 316‑8323

4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews
Ryan answers it · on video

Watch on YouTubeRead the transcript

The short version

What to take from this.

  • A compromise nobody believes in lands for nobody. The number was never the real fight.
  • A trial is temporary, so it asks less of each parent than a permanent concession does.
  • Tracking what actually happens gives you real information to decide with, instead of two predictions.
  • Working together on the trial builds a small record of cooperation, which often changes the conversation. More on what happens when you can't agree on parenting time.
  • Every family's schedule is different. Here's how parenting time mediation in Minnesota works start to finish.

Transcript

In Ryan’s words.

What Ryan says in the video, written out.

Watch me settle a 50-50 custody war. Okay, so check this out. You have a dad who's asking for 50/50 parent time. You have a mom who's saying, "I want a 75/25 split where I get 75, you get 25." And it seems like they're intractably stuck in this position where they're both firmly planted and they're both saying, "All right, let's go to court." So, the tempting thing for a mediator to do is to say, "Let's split the difference." Right? There's 14 nights. Like we could analyze this in 30 days per month or 14. It's easily with a 14-day rotation of say 14 days.

You know one of you is at 7 and 7, the other one is at 3 and 11. Let's split the difference and go 9 overnights to mom, five overnights to dad. That's halfway between your two positions. And does that work? And they'll say no. I'll say, "No, it doesn't work because the dad is fighting for equality and the mom is saying like, "You just haven't been around." so why should you start now? This is a really, really, really hard problem to solve. If it weren't hard, there wouldn't be family court lawyers and contested custody cases.

So, what I'm about to offer is one possible way to look at this, which is, can we do a trial? Can we stipulate and agree to try each party's position and gather data and come back? No, no one's going to like trying the other person's perspective, but you can gather measurable data. And just by going through that exercise of working together and agreeing to something, you build positive experience. You build a record of being able to work together and validate the other person's perspective. And from that, two things are likely to happen.

You're likely to see each other in a different light and therefore because you see each other in a different light, the calculus will change. And this is a way to get movement between parties who aren't willing to step off their position permanently, but they're willing to temporarily try something. My name is Ryan. I'm a divorce mediator. Some more.

A tool for this, from Flannel People

Two-Home Calendar and Expense Template$29

A 12-month shared calendar, a holiday rotation, and a shared-expense tracker, for Excel or Google Sheets.

See the template
Ryan McLaughlin, divorce mediator in St. Paul, Minnesota, on a Zoom call
Ryan McLaughlin · St. Paul

Who’s answering

Ryan McLaughlin, mediator. Flannel, not a suit.

Ryan founded Flannel People Mediation in St. Paul and mediates divorces for couples all over Minnesota, mostly on Zoom, for one flat fee. He has an MFA in creative writing and a lot of kitchen-table money conversations behind him. Flannel People has 4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews. Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, so he doesn’t give legal advice or take sides.

Questions

What people ask next.

Something not here? Text Ryan.

Why doesn't splitting the difference work for parenting time?

Because each parent is usually arguing for something underneath the number. One wants to be treated as an equal parent; the other is worried about consistency or about who has been doing the day-to-day. A 9 and 5 schedule doesn't speak to either concern, so both parents turn it down.

What does a parenting time trial look like?

The two of you agree to run one parent's proposed schedule for a set stretch, then the other's, and keep track of how the kids, the logistics, and the handoffs actually go. Then you sit down together and look at what you learned. Nothing about a trial is permanent, and it works best when both of you agree to it.

What if one of us refuses to try the other's schedule?

That's common, and it's worth talking about what the refusal protects. Mediation can also look at smaller versions of a trial, a shorter stretch or one part of the schedule. If you're still stuck, the reasons behind each position are usually the next thing to work through. See how to break a 50/50 fight without arguing about percentages.

How much does divorce mediation cost at Flannel People?

Divorce mediation is $1,695 per person, flat, with no hourly billing. That covers a private call with each of you, written prep, and one prepared three-hour session on Zoom. In-person options may be available on request, for an additional fee. Your court's filing fee is separate, and so is an attorney if either of you wants one to review the agreement. See what the flat fee includes and what divorce costs in Minnesota. Already divorced and changing a schedule? That's post-divorce mediation, $995 per person, flat. See parenting time mediation in Minnesota.

Can I book the first call by myself?

Yes. You can book the free 15-minute consultation on your own. Nothing is scheduled until you've both said yes.

Keep reading

We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice.

The free call

Pick a time. 15 minutes.

I call you at the time you pick. Come alone or together. You tell me where things stand, I tell you honestly whether mediation fits, and you don’t agree to anything on the call.

Loading scheduler...

Educational Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice, therapeutic advice, or therapy. Flannel People Mediation is a mediation service provider only. We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice. We do not provide therapeutic services. For legal questions, talk to your own attorney or the court's Self-Help Center.

Flannel People Mediation provides mediation services only. Ryan McLaughlin does not provide legal, insurance, valuation, tax, financial, or business advice, and mediation does not replace your own counsel or advisors.

Follow our work in Google

Tell Google you want to see more of our writing on divorce and mediation. It takes one tick of a box, and it changes your results, not ours.

Make us a preferred source