What does a mediator do about an eye roll in divorce mediation?
Short answer
An eye roll is a classic sign of contempt, which relationship researcher John Gottman calls one of the Four Horsemen, the patterns that predict divorce. When Ryan sees one in mediation, his default is to let it pass: he restates the first person's reasons and keeps the conversation moving, because mediation isn't therapy. If the eye rolls become a pattern, he doesn't call them out. He asks what's underneath: when they say 50/50, what are you hearing? People who feel heard get less defensive, and that's when they can start building something together.
15 minutes, free. Or text Ryan: (763) 316‑8323
The short version
What to take from this.
- Contempt says "I'm better than you." Gottman's research links it strongly to divorce.
- One eye roll: Ryan usually restates what was said and moves on. The goal is an agreement, not analysis.
- A pattern of eye rolls usually means someone doesn't feel heard. The fix is a question, not a callout.
- Mediation, not therapy. See what a mediator can and can't do.
Transcript
In Ryan’s words.
What Ryan says in the video, written out.
If you're watching this, you know that the eye roll, when someone rolls their eyes in a conversation, even if it's a half a second, is a sign of contempt. This has been studied and reported again and again and again. John Gottman, psychologist, studied it for years. He calls it one of the four horsemen, one of those things that you can do that predicts divorce. And it it's a sign of contempt. It's a sign that you think you're morally superior than someone. It's a very very strong predictor. Question is, what do I do about it when I see it in a mediation between two folks who are separating?
My name's Ryan. I'm a mediator in Minnesota. I do divorce mediation. We site research. I show up as a human being. And we'll talk more about what both of those things mean. But let's get back to this. What do I do with contempt? What do I do with the eye roll? When someone says, "Hey, I'm thinking we should do 50-50 parenting for the kids." The other party rolls their eyes. Two things, right? One, I'll ignore it. And I've experimented with both and I do research on both. I'll ignore it. I will I will look to the other person. I will look to the person.
So, person A says, "Let's do 50/50." I'll look to person B and say, "I'm hearing that person A for reason A, reason B, reason C is feeling like 50/50 was able to best meet those goals and objectives, you know, having and I'll ignore the eye roll. I'll just proceed, right? I'll just move forward." And the reason why is isn't because it does it deserves doesn't deserve attention. It does deserve attention, but it's not central to our product, to our project, to our goal, to our mission, to our purpose, which is helping these folks proceed through the conversation.
And this is a key difference between mediation and therapy. I'm not here to psychoanalyze everything. I'm not here to like squeeze the juice of every nugget that presents itself and do Freudian analysis. To the extent that's relevant is the extent maybe we can is the extent to which can it help these two folks come to an agreement. That's why they're coming to me. They're coming to me to solve a problem to untie a knot that they can't untie themselves to bridge a gap that they can't build the bridge themselves. And so that's the first thing.
That's like option one. That's my default. And it's important to know why. The second thing is if there's a trend like if it's a sign of resistance if it's a sign that there's something deeper that needs to be said part of and a huge part of why there's resistance is because someone doesn't feel heard and if there's like one of the core jobs of a mediator is to allow create space for and I hate the saying create space but to allow both people to feel heard and psychologically we person A can talk and person B can talk they've been talking together for years, but they don't hear each other.
It just says like dead deaf. They're deaf to each other. And so, if I say the exact same thing that person A says, person A says it, I repeat it, and person B hears it differently because they don't have neural pathways about me yet. So, everything that I say is kind of fresh and new and they're actually hearing it. So I might ask like if I notice it's a trend. If I notice the eye rolls are a trend from person B, I might ask person B, not necessarily about the eye rolls. I don't need to point out the eye rolls or the huffs, but I might say like, what story is happening here when they say they want 50/50 for you?
What are you hearing in that? And allow them the opportunity to speak to them, to speak to it themselves. Allow them to give words to the eye roll. And sort of vocalize what their body is trying to vocalize. In an in the attempt that if they can speak their what they need to speak and feel heard like someone hears them, it can lower defensiveness. It can lower heart rate. That can put them in a better mood to be to to make to mold the clay together. My name's Ryan. If you like this, if you need this kind of help, if you want to grow a mediation practice like this, follow for more, message me.
I love when folks retail.
A tool for this, from Flannel People
Unstick the Room: 34 Research-Backed Tools for Hard Conversations$47
34 tools for the moment a conversation is flooded, defensive, or looping, each with when to use it and words to try.

Who’s answering
Ryan McLaughlin, mediator. Flannel, not a suit.
Ryan founded Flannel People Mediation in St. Paul and mediates divorces for couples all over Minnesota, mostly on Zoom, for one flat fee. He has an MFA in creative writing and a lot of kitchen-table money conversations behind him. Flannel People has 4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews. Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, so he doesn’t give legal advice or take sides.
What are Gottman's Four Horsemen?
Criticism, contempt, defensiveness, and stonewalling: four communication patterns that psychologist John Gottman found predict the end of a relationship. Contempt is considered the strongest predictor.
Why doesn't the mediator call out the eye roll?
Because naming it usually makes the person defensive. Asking what they're hearing gives them words for what their body already said, which is more likely to move the conversation.
What's the difference between mediation and therapy here?
A therapist might explore the eye roll. A mediator asks whether it gets in the way of an agreement, and works on it only as far as it does.
How much does divorce mediation cost at Flannel People?
$1,695 per person, flat, with no hourly billing. That covers a private call with each of you, written prep, and one prepared three-hour session on Zoom. In-person options may be available on request, for an additional fee. Your court's filing fee is separate, and so is an attorney if either of you wants one to review the agreement. See what the flat fee includes and what divorce costs in Minnesota.
Can I book the first call by myself?
Yes. You can book the free 15-minute consultation on your own. Nothing is scheduled until you've both said yes.
Related questions
Ryan answers these on video, too.
- Conflict skills and researchWhy does your spouse's idea sound worse during a divorce? It's called reactive devaluationWatch and read
- Conflict skills and researchHow can two opposite things about your co-parent both be true after divorce?Watch and read
- How mediation worksCan't talk to your spouse about the divorce? How divorce mediation still worksWatch and read
- Parenting timeOne parent wants 50/50 custody and the other says no. What happens in divorce mediation?Watch and read
Keep reading
- Repair attemptsThe small moves that pull a conversation back.
- The research behind the roomWhy calm, structured conversations go better.
- Divorce mediation, flat feeThe three-part process and what the fee covers.
We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice.
The free call
Pick a time. 15 minutes.
I call you at the time you pick. Come alone or together. You tell me where things stand, I tell you honestly whether mediation fits, and you don’t agree to anything on the call.
Loading scheduler...