Why does your spouse's idea sound worse during a divorce? It's called reactive devaluation

Short answer

It's called reactive devaluation: people tend to rate the same proposal lower when it comes from the other side of a conflict. Psychologists Lee Ross and Constance Stillinger wrote about it in 1991. Your spouse's idea gets stacked with all the history, emotions, and old fights between you, so it never gets heard on its own merits. It's a big part of why a neutral person helps: the same parenting schedule can sound atrocious from your spouse and reasonable from a mediator. The percentages in the video come from a published negotiation study, named in the questions below. That study measured reactions to a nuclear-arms proposal, not to a spouse's idea in a divorce.

Pick my free 15-min call time

15 minutes, free. Or text Ryan: (763) 316‑8323

4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews
Ryan answers it · on video

Watch on YouTubeRead the transcript

The short version

What to take from this.

  • The idea doesn't change. Who says it changes how it lands.
  • The research behind the name came from negotiation studies, not divorce. Ryan's point is that the same pattern shows up at the kitchen table.
  • In couples therapy it's the date-night idea you suggested weeks ago. In mediation it's the schedule.
  • A neutral can restate a proposal so it gets heard on its merits. See how a mediator settles a 50/50 standoff.

Transcript

In Ryan’s words.

What Ryan says in the video, written out.

Okay, chances are if you've been in therapy, couples therapy, you've seen this before where you've told your spouse like, "Hey, I think the problem is that like we need to go on more date nights or we need to put the kids to bed earlier and stay up late and have some connective time or whatever the whatever the thing is, like you've made a suggestion on how things could be could be different." And in the divorce mediation world, it's like one person makes a proposal like, "I think a parenting time schedule for us could be this."

And they reject it. They say, "No, maybe before this sentence even gets out of your mouth." And like that idea makes no sense. And then it comes up in with the therapist or the mediator and the person says like the therapist says, "have you know, have you guys like there's a lot of research on like spending time together, going on date nights. Have you guys ever thought of a date night?" And the person's like, "That's a really good idea." And then you think to yourself, dude, I said that. I said that like 3 weeks ago and you told me no.

But when it comes from the couple's the when it comes from the therapist, it's suddenly magic. Same thing with divorce mediation. You know, 50/50 schedule, week on, week off. Sounds atrocious when the partner says it, but if the mediator says like, "Hey, I hear like, you know, you're saying 50/50 week on there's a lot of research, you know, like that sound that 's that's the proposal I'm hearing." And there's research on this. There's research on why you can't hear it from your significant other on your partner, your spouse, but you can hear it from a neutral.

So, psychologists measured this in 1991. So, it's old established research. You can Google Ross and Stillinger. And they took this exact scenario. And here's what they found. When the idea comes from themselves, meaning me, my idea, I rate it favorably 90% of the time. Makes sense. When it comes from a neutral third party, i.e. Me a mediator. If I pitch the idea, they rate it favorably 80% of the time. So, a little bit of a decline. When the idea comes from the other person, i.e. Your spouse, they rate it 44% rate it favorably 44% of the time.

So, you're basically twice as likely to agree to something in the present the same exact thing. Sure, go to the water park today because it's super hot out. Mediator says it, therapist says it, twice as likely to agree as if your the other party says it. And the idea here is that we discount what our significant other says because we're stacking in our brains all the previous history, all the previous emotions, all the previous trauma. Guys, my name is Ryan. I'm a mediator with Flannel People Mediation. This is what you get when you come to Flannel Mediation.

A process, a person steeped in what works and why it works. Our goal is to turn to turn folks who can't talk about this into folks who just decided everything themselves amicably on an efficient timeline. So, bring to us the idea in your house or in your conversation that got a no a hard no and we'll see what we can do. My name is Ryan. Reach out if you have questions. We'll see you guys later.

A tool for this, from Flannel People

Unstick the Room: 34 Research-Backed Tools for Hard Conversations$47

34 tools for the moment a conversation is flooded, defensive, or looping, each with when to use it and words to try.

See the tools
Ryan McLaughlin, divorce mediator in St. Paul, Minnesota, on a Zoom call
Ryan McLaughlin · St. Paul

Who’s answering

Ryan McLaughlin, mediator. Flannel, not a suit.

Ryan founded Flannel People Mediation in St. Paul and mediates divorces for couples all over Minnesota, mostly on Zoom, for one flat fee. He has an MFA in creative writing and a lot of kitchen-table money conversations behind him. Flannel People has 4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews. Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, so he doesn’t give legal advice or take sides.

Questions

What people ask next.

Something not here? Text Ryan.

What is reactive devaluation?

A bias where people discount a proposal because of who offered it, especially when it comes from someone they see as on the other side. It's well documented in negotiation research, including work by Lee Ross and Constance Stillinger.

How does a mediator get around it?

By restating what each person proposed, with their reasons, in neutral words. Coming from someone without your shared history, the same idea often gets a fairer hearing.

What can I do about it at home?

Notice when you're reacting to who said something instead of what was said. Ask yourself whether you'd consider it if a friend had suggested it.

How much does divorce mediation cost at Flannel People?

$1,695 per person, flat, with no hourly billing. That covers a private call with each of you, written prep, and one prepared three-hour session on Zoom. In-person options may be available on request, for an additional fee. Your court's filing fee is separate, and so is an attorney if either of you wants one to review the agreement. See what the flat fee includes and what divorce costs in Minnesota.

Where do the 90 percent, 80 percent, and 44 percent figures in the video come from?

From a 1986 sidewalk survey reported by Constance Stillinger, Michael Epelbaum, Dacher Keltner, and Lee Ross, and described by Lee Ross in Reactive Devaluation in Negotiation and Conflict Resolution: (https://law.stanford.edu/index.php?webauth-document=child-page/370999/doc/slspublic/Reactive+Devaluation.pdf). People rated the same nuclear-arms proposal as favorable to the United States or evenhanded 90 percent of the time when it was attributed to President Reagan, 80 percent when attributed to unnamed strategy analysts, and 44 percent when attributed to Mikhail Gorbachev. The survey was not a study of divorcing spouses, and this page does not treat those figures as divorce statistics.

Keep reading

We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice.

The free call

Pick a time. 15 minutes.

I call you at the time you pick. Come alone or together. You tell me where things stand, I tell you honestly whether mediation fits, and you don’t agree to anything on the call.

Loading scheduler...

Educational Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice, therapeutic advice, or therapy. Flannel People Mediation is a mediation service provider only. We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice. We do not provide therapeutic services. For legal questions, talk to your own attorney or the court's Self-Help Center.

Flannel People Mediation provides mediation services only. Ryan McLaughlin does not provide legal, insurance, valuation, tax, financial, or business advice, and mediation does not replace your own counsel or advisors.

Follow our work in Google

Tell Google you want to see more of our writing on divorce and mediation. It takes one tick of a box, and it changes your results, not ours.

Make us a preferred source