Who should not use divorce mediation?

Short answer

Do not use a joint mediation session if you are afraid of the other person, if someone is there to punish rather than decide, if untreated addiction or a mental health crisis is blocking a real decision, or if you need an emergency court order today. Anger, distrust, and disagreement do not by themselves rule mediation out. This is general information, not legal advice. If you are in danger, contact a domestic violence advocate or law enforcement.

Pick my free 15-min call time

15 minutes, free. Or text Ryan: (763) 316‑8323

4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews
Ryan answers it · on video

Watch on YouTubeRead the transcript

The short version

What to take from this.

  • Safety comes first. Fear and coercive control make a voluntary agreement impossible.
  • Mediation is not an emergency court tool.
  • Being angry or deeply distrustful is not the same list.
  • Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Say the hard part on the free call, before a joint session.

Transcript

In Ryan’s words.

What Ryan says in the video, written out.

I'm going to do something unusual for a mediator right now. I'm going to talk you out of hiring me. Or at least I'm going to tell you clearly who should not use mediation, because the worst option is that folks use mediation who weren't right for the situation. So in this video, here's the honest list of who mediation isn't appropriate for, so you can make the right call even if that means taking a different path. So there are four general situations where I would tell you, generally speaking, not to mediate. Again, not legal advice, just general information, educational purposes only, from my perspective as a mediator. Talk to your lawyer specifically if you want legal advice for you. I'm not your lawyer, just general information.

First, active domestic violence or coercive control. Huge. Now, I want to be precise here, because these terms get thrown around a lot and used kind of loosely in ways that matter. So let's define terms. Coercive control means one person in the relationship is using fear, isolation, financial control, threats, to dominate the other. And when that's present, mediation is just ineffective. In fact, it's potentially harmful, because the fearful partner can't negotiate freely. Because anything that they agree to in the room can't be considered voluntary. The structure of the mediation assumes, this is like a prerequisite, that two people have a roughly equal capacity to speak and be heard. And coercive control, like if you're worried about what's going to happen after mediation as a consequence of what you say in mediation, eliminates that assumption. And so if this is your situation, a domestic violence advocate, an attorney, and possibly the court getting involved are the right resources, because we need safety as a prerequisite to have that kind of mediation.

Number two. One spouse is committed to smiting, punishing, destroying the other person, and wants to use mediation as a way to do that, and they're not at all interested in resolution. You can see why this would make sense. And this is, from my experience, rare. But it is real, and it's worth naming. So some people enter the divorce process, or mediation generally, with the sole goal of making the other person suffer. Financially, relationally, publicly. And there's not an agreement in the world that would satisfy that person unless it destroys the other. And that's not a negotiating partner. That's not good faith. That's not something that mediation can help or fix.

Third. Active, untreated is important, addiction or serious mental health which affects your current cognitive ability to function and process. So this isn't a history of addiction or a history of mental health issues. It's not past struggles. It's active, untreated, currently affecting your capacity to make and honor decisions. Mediation can't address that and work with those.

Fourth, and lastly, are emergencies requiring immediate court intervention. Which is to say, if your spouse, as an example, is about to drain a bank account or liquidate assets generally. If there's a custody crisis happening right now. If you need an emergency protective order right now, you need the court's emergency powers, and mediation isn't an emergency tool, for a whole host of reasons. So those are the four, generally speaking.

Now let's talk about what doesn't disqualify you, what mediation still works for. Anger. Even a lot of anger. Even a history of conflict. Even infidelity. Even deep distrust. Even deep disagreements on basically everything. Having an attorney, you still can mediate. Having been to court before, you still can mediate. None of these things disqualify you. So the bar for this disqualifies us, this is too much for mediation, is actually higher than most people think. So I say that not to sell you on a service, but because I've seen many people, and talked to many people in consults, who think, oh, we're not quite amicable enough, and so they disqualify themselves for mediation when in fact they'd be great candidates. They would have a net net, I think, and the data shows, less stressful, less expense, less cost, less time than if they were going the litigation route. Again, not everybody, just general information. Check it out. Free consultation, flannelpeoplemediation.com. My name's Ryan. I'm a mediator with Flannel People Mediation. Let's figure out if this is the right path for you. Thanks for watching.

Free from Flannel People

How a Prepared Mediation Works

A short free video course on how the whole process goes, start to finish, at your own pace.

Get the free course
Ryan McLaughlin, divorce mediator in St. Paul, Minnesota, on a Zoom call
Ryan McLaughlin · St. Paul

Who’s answering

Ryan McLaughlin, mediator. Flannel, not a suit.

Ryan founded Flannel People Mediation in St. Paul and mediates divorces for couples all over Minnesota, mostly on Zoom, for one flat fee. He has an MFA in creative writing and a lot of kitchen-table money conversations behind him. Flannel People has 4.9 stars from 292 Google reviews. Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, so he doesn’t give legal advice or take sides.

Questions

What people ask next.

Something not here? Text Ryan.

What are the situations mediation is not for?

Fear or coercive control, a person who wants to punish rather than decide, an active untreated crisis that blocks a real decision, and a need for an emergency court order. If you are in danger, contact a domestic violence advocate or law enforcement.

Does a lot of anger disqualify us?

No. The video treats anger, distrust, and strong disagreement as workable. Fear is different. Say which one you are dealing with on the free call.

Can we still mediate if we each have a lawyer?

Yes. Having your own attorney does not rule mediation out. Your mediator still does not give legal advice.

Who is the mediator?

Your mediator may be Ryan or Kate. Ryan is a mediator, not your lawyer.

How much does divorce mediation cost at Flannel People?

$1,695 per person, flat, with no hourly billing. That covers a private call with each of you, written prep, and one prepared three-hour session on Zoom. In-person options may be available on request, for an additional fee. Your court's filing fee is separate, and so is an attorney if either of you wants one to review the agreement you write together. See what divorce mediation costs in Minnesota and what the flat fee includes.

Keep reading

We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice.

The free call

Pick a time. 15 minutes.

I call you at the time you pick. Come alone or together. You tell me where things stand, I tell you honestly whether mediation fits, and you don’t agree to anything on the call.

Loading scheduler...

Educational Disclaimer: The information provided on this website is for educational purposes only and is not intended as legal advice, therapeutic advice, or therapy. Flannel People Mediation is a mediation service provider only. We help two people who don't agree on really tricky issues come to an agreement and put that agreement in writing. We don't draft court documents, we don't file, we don't do anything with the courts, and we don't give legal advice. We do not provide therapeutic services. For legal questions, talk to your own attorney or the court's Self-Help Center.

Flannel People Mediation provides mediation services only. Ryan McLaughlin does not provide legal, insurance, valuation, tax, financial, or business advice, and mediation does not replace your own counsel or advisors.

Follow our work in Google

Tell Google you want to see more of our writing on divorce and mediation. It takes one tick of a box, and it changes your results, not ours.

Make us a preferred source